Megha 205_apeal_1293_2011.doc
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
CRIMINAL APPEAL NO.1293 OF 2011
Sidhram Sambhaji Suryavanshi …Appellant
Versus
The State of Maharashtra …Respondent
…..
Ms Nasreen Ayubi, appointed Advocate for the Appellant.
Mr. P.H. Gaikwad, APP for the Respondent -State.
CORAM : SMT. ANUJA PRABHUDESSAI, J.
DATED: 7th DECEMBER, 2017.
JUDGMENT :-
The Appellant, who was an accused (hereinafter referred to
as ‘accused’) in Sessions Case No.678 of 2010 has challenged the
judgment dated 29th August, 2011 whereby the learned Additional
Sessions Judge, Pune, held him guilty of offences punishable under
Sections 376 and 506 of the IPC and sentenced him to undergo
rigorous imprisonment for a period of ten years and to pay fine of
Rs.1,000/- i/d. to undergo rigorous imprisonment for three months in
respect of offence under Section 376 of the IPC and rigorous
imprisonment for two years with fine of Rs.500/- i/d. to undergo
rigorous imprisonment for two months for offence under Section 506
of the IPC. Both the sentences were ordered to be run concurrently.
Megha 1/5
::: Uploaded on – 12/12/2017 13/12/2017 01:05:41 :::
Megha 205_apeal_1293_2011.doc
2. The accused is the step father of the victim girl. It is the
case of the prosecution that the prosecutrix is the daughter of one
Bhimabai. The husband of Bhimabai had deserted her and her
daughter. Subsequently, said Bhimabai married the accused and
started residing with him alongwith her minor daughter. It is the case
of the prosecution that the accused had committed rape on prosecutrix
being his step daughter. Bhimabai, mother of the prosecutrix lodged
the FIR, pursuant to which Crime No.157 of 2010 under Sections 376
and 506 of the IPC came to be registered against the accused. The
victim was examined by the Medical Officer at Sasoon Hospital. PW5
Rajendra Giri-PSI arrested the accused, recorded the statements of the
witnesses and on completing the investigation, submitted the charge
sheet.
3. The case being sessions triable, the same was committed to
the Court of Sessions at Pune. The charge was explained to the
accused. The accused pleaded not guilty and claimed to be tried. The
prosecution examined five witnesses. The statement of the accused
was recorded under Section 313 of the Cr.P.C. The defence of the
accused was that of total denial. The learned Additional Sessions
Judge, Pune, after appreciating the evidence on record held the
Megha 2/5
::: Uploaded on – 12/12/2017 13/12/2017 01:05:41 :::
Megha 205_apeal_1293_2011.doc
accused guilty of the offences under Sections 376 and 506 of the IPC
and sentenced him as stated above. Being aggrieved by the conviction
and sentence, the accused has preferred this Appeal.
4. Heard Ms Nasreen Ayubi, learned counsel for the accused
and Mr. P.H. Gaikwad, learned APP for the Respondent -State. Perused
the records.
5. The evidence of PW1-Bhimabai, indicates that the
prosecutrix is her daughter from her first marriage. Her husband-
Sikander Kamble had deserted her and thereafter she married the
accused- Sidharam Suryavanshi and started residing with him
alongwith her minor daughter. She has stated that the prosecutrix was
born on 27.11.2004 and at the relevant time she was about 6 years of
age. She has stated that she used to sleep on cot with her younger
daughter while prosecutrix used to sleep on floor alongwith the
accused. She has stated that during the intervening night of 15 th April,
2010 and 16th April, 2010 at about 2.00 a.m. she found that the
accused was lying over her minor daughter. She has stated that the
accused had removed his underwear as well as the underwear of the
prosecutrix. When she questioned the accused he shouted at her and
Megha 3/5
::: Uploaded on – 12/12/2017 13/12/2017 01:05:41 :::
Megha 205_apeal_1293_2011.doc
intimidated her. In the next morning her daughter complained of
abdominal pain. She informed about the incident to her neighbour
Padmini, who examined the private part of prosecutrix, which
appeared to be reddish in colour. Therefore, Bhimabai went to Dapodi
Police Station and lodged the FIR, which is at Exh.-11.
6. PW4- Padmini who is neighbour of the first informant has
confirmed that on 16.4.2010 at about 9.00 a.m. PW1-Bhimabai had
informed her about the incident. She has stated that she had
questioned the prosecutrix, who appeared to be frightened. She has
stated that the prosecutrix had narrated that her father had pulled her
nicker upto her knees and penetrated his penis in her private part and
had sexual intercourse with her.
7. PW3-Dr. Milind Waghmare had examined the prosecutrix.
He has deposed that the victim was about six years of age. He has
stated that genital examination of the victim showed that hymen was
completely torn with perihymonal inflammation with tenderness. The
Doctor has opined that there was evidence of penetrative vaginal
intercourse. He has produced medical examination report at Exh.-19.
Megha 4/5
::: Uploaded on – 12/12/2017 13/12/2017 01:05:41 :::
Megha 205_apeal_1293_2011.doc
8. The prosecutrix has also deposed that on the relevant night
she was sleeping with the accused, who is her step father. She had
confirmed that the accused had removed her underwear and had
inserted his private part in her vagina.
9. The evidence on record proves beyond reasonable doubt
that the accused had sexual intercourse with his step daughter, who at
the relevant time was six years of age. The medical evidence also
proves that the hymen of the victim was completely torn with
perihymonal inflammation and thus corroborates the evidence of PW1
and the prosecutrix.
10. The evidence adduced by the prosecution therefore proves
beyond reasonable doubt that the Appellant herein had committed
rape on his minor step daughter, who at the relevant time was barely
six years of age. The findings recorded by the learned Trial Judge are
based on evidence on record. There is neither any illegality or
perversity in the findings recorded by the learned Judge. The Appeal
has no merits and is accordingly dismissed.
(ANUJA PRABHUDESSAI, J.)
Megha 5/5
::: Uploaded on – 12/12/2017 13/12/2017 01:05:41 :::
